Thick, Yellow Toenails? Why Spring Is the Time to Deal With Them

The first warm weekend of spring, and the thongs come back out. That's usually when people notice.

Every September there's a week where the weather turns and half of South East Queensland digs the thongs out of the cupboard.

That same week my inbox fills up with a particular kind of message. Someone has looked at their feet properly for the first time since about April, and a big toenail has gone thick and yellow. Maybe it's crumbly at the end, or lifting off the skin underneath. It sat under socks all winter and nobody thought about it, and now it's on show at the barbecue.

The question is nearly always the same: can you fix this before summer?

I'd rather give you the honest answer now than in December, because the honest answer is usually no, and September is still the right time to start.

What's probably going on

A thick, yellow, crumbling toenail is most often a fungal nail infection. The medical name is onychomycosis. When the usual skin fungi are the cause, you'll also see it called tinea unguium, which just means tinea of the nail. It's very common. A 2024 review of more than 100 studies put toenail fungus at about 4% of the general population, and noticeably higher in older people and people with diabetes. In a podiatry clinic it feels like a lot more than that, because those are the people who come in.

It usually starts on the skin. Fungi like warm, damp, dark places, and the inside of a work boot on a Queensland foot in February is about as good as it gets. Often there's tinea between the toes first (the itchy, flaky, split skin), and from there it gets under the edge of the nail. Once it's inside the nail plate, it's living in a hard shell with no blood supply. That detail explains most of what follows.

You're more likely to get it with sweaty feet in closed shoes, a nail that's taken a knock, shared showers at the gym or pool, getting older, or diabetes.

Got a nail you're not happy with? We look at the whole foot, not just the nail, at our Caboolture, Beenleigh, Browns Plains and Victoria Point clinics.

Book an appointment

The timeline nobody mentions

I explain this at almost every one of these appointments, so I'll put it in writing.

Toenails are slow. A study that had people mark and measure their own nails found toenails grow about 1.6mm a month, and the big toenail is the quickest of them. Do the maths on a big toenail and you get roughly a year from the base to the tip, often longer in older feet. The yellow part you can see now will never turn clear. With no blood supply, nothing you paint on it or swallow repairs that bit. Treatment stops the fungus so the new nail grows in clean, and then you wait for the old part to grow off the end.

That's also why the research trials of nail lacquers run for close to a year before anyone judges the result. So the answer to "before summer?" is no, not for the nail you have today. But start in September and the clean nail has three extra months of growing behind it by Christmas compared with starting the week before.

Bare feet in thongs on timber decking on a warm spring day in South East Queensland
Thongs, pools and communal showers are all part of a Queensland summer, and all part of how nail fungus gets around.

Before you treat it, make sure it's actually fungus

Plenty of thick, discoloured toenails that land in my chair aren't fungal. A review of conditions that mimic nail fungus found that in damaged, thickened nails, fungus is the cause in only about half of cases.

An old injury can permanently thicken a nail and make it look almost the same. I mean a dropped dumbbell, a season in football boots half a size too small, or years of running in shoes with no room at the front. Psoriasis can do it too, and so can a toe that sits on top of its neighbour. I've seen people spend a year and a fair bit of money painting antifungal lacquer onto what was only ever a very old bruise.

So the first job is working out what we're dealing with. That means looking at the nail, the skin, the shoes and the shape of your foot. If it still isn't clear, I'll take a small clipping and send it to a lab. The result takes a few weeks to come back, because fungus is slow to grow in a dish as well as on a toe.

What treatment actually looks like

There's no single fix, and anyone who promises one is overselling it. A plan is usually built from some of these:

  • Reducing the nail. Thinning a thick nail takes the pressure off and stops it catching on socks. It also means anything you put on it has a chance of reaching the fungus instead of sitting on top of a wall of keratin.
  • Topical antifungals, meaning the lacquers and solutions from the chemist. The Cochrane review of topical treatments found some of them do better than a dummy treatment, but the studies were mostly in mild to moderate infections that hadn't reached the base of the nail, and they ask for daily use for months.
  • Tablets. These need a prescription and they aren't right for everyone, because they can interact with other medicines. A Cochrane review led from the University of Queensland found high-quality evidence that terbinafine works better than placebo. Pooled trials put its fungal cure rate at about 76%, so it's the strongest option and still not a sure thing. That's a conversation for your GP, and I'm happy to write to them.
  • Treating the skin as well. People skip this one. If the tinea between your toes stays, it walks straight back into the nail.
  • Sorting out the shoes. If the nail gets crushed every day, the antifungal is fighting uphill. Sometimes general foot care and a change of footwear do more than any bottle.

Stopping it coming back

Getting it again is what undoes all that patience. Mostly it comes down to dull habits:

  • Dry properly between the toes, not just over the top of the foot
  • Don't wear the same closed shoes two days running. Give them a day to dry out
  • Wear thongs in communal showers, at the pool and at the gym
  • Keep your towel to yourself, and wash socks hot
  • Keep treating the skin a bit longer than feels necessary

Nail clippers are the one people forget. If the same clippers go through the infected nail and then the healthy ones, you're just moving the fungus along the row. Clean them, or keep a separate pair.

When it's worth booking in

I'd like to see it if the nail is getting thicker or starting to hurt, if it's spreading to the nails next door, if it catches on your socks, or if a chemist product has had a genuine few months and nothing has changed.

If you have diabetes or poor circulation, don't sit on it. A thick nail can press down on the nail bed and break the skin underneath, and in a foot that heals slowly that matters a lot more than how the nail looks. Catching that early is a large part of what routine foot care is for.

One more. If the nail hurts down the side rather than being thick across the middle, it's probably a different problem, usually an ingrown toenail. That's treated a completely different way and takes a lot less than a year to sort out.

Questions I get asked about this

How long does a fungal toenail take to clear?

Longer than most people expect. Toenails grow roughly 1.5mm a month, so a big toenail takes about a year, sometimes more, to grow from the base to the tip. The damaged part of the nail never turns clear again. It has to grow off the end, so treatment needs to run for most of that time.

Are all thick yellow toenails fungal?

No. In studies of thickened, damaged nails, fungus turns out to be the cause in only about half. An old knock, years of pressure from tight shoes and psoriasis can all change a nail in a similar way. That is why we assess the nail, and sometimes send a sample to the lab, before making a plan.

Can I just use something from the chemist?

You can, and it is a reasonable start for a mild infection in the outer part of the nail. The trials of nail lacquers were mostly in mild to moderate infections that had not reached the base of the nail. If a few months of daily use has changed nothing, get the nail looked at rather than buying another bottle.

Is it contagious?

It can spread to your other nails and to the skin of your feet, and it can be picked up in shared wet areas. Drying between the toes, not sharing towels and wearing thongs in communal showers all reduce the risk.

Will it come back?

It can, particularly if the skin infection between the toes was never treated or the shoes never changed. The prevention habits are the half of the job that decides whether you do this once or every few years.

Want to get it started properly? We'll work out what the nail actually is, thin it down, and set up a plan you can stick to, with realistic timeframes rather than promises. Clinics at Caboolture, Beenleigh, Browns Plains and Victoria Point across South East Queensland.

Book an appointment

References & further reading

This is general information, not individual advice. Nail changes can have several causes, so please have your feet assessed properly by a podiatrist or your GP.


← Back to blog