Orthotics and Custom Footwear: When They Actually Help

A well-made orthotic changes how your foot is loaded. It's a tool, and it works best as part of a plan.

"Do I need orthotics?" is one of the questions I get asked most. Usually it comes from someone who has already tried three pairs of shoes and a chemist insole and is still sore. My honest answer is sometimes yes and sometimes no. Orthotics are useful, but there's a lot of confusion about what they do and when they're worth the money, so here is how I think about it.

What an orthotic actually does

Foot orthoses (orthotics) are shoe inserts that change how load moves through your foot. They can support an area that's working too hard, take pressure off a sore spot, or shift your foot into a position that's easier on irritated tissue. I don't think of them as "correcting" feet the way braces straighten teeth. They change the load while you're wearing them, and they don't permanently reshape anything.

For the right problem, that change can help. In one Australian trial of people with plantar fasciopathy, custom orthoses worn in new shoes eased first-step pain more than new shoes alone or a sham insert over 12 weeks.

Custom orthotics and shoe modifications being made in a podiatry lab
Custom devices and footwear modification come into their own for feet that are harder to fit.

Custom or off-the-shelf?

People are often surprised by this one. For plantar heel pain, a review comparing custom and prefabricated orthoses found no clear difference between them at any time point, and a second review found neither type did much better than a sham insole for short-term pain. So I won't send you down the custom path just because it sounds more impressive.

Custom devices earn their keep when the foot is more complex: a marked deformity, a big difference between your two feet, or a specific pressure area that an off-the-shelf shape can't reach. Diabetes is a big one. The Australian guideline on preventing diabetes-related foot ulcers lists orthotic devices and medical grade footwear among the things that may help prevent ulcers. That's also where footwear modification comes in. It's the pedorthic side of the work, which the Pedorthic Association of Australia describes as providing medical grade footwear and orthotic appliances, including adjusting ready-made shoes and making custom ones.

Been sold orthotics before and not sure they helped? We'll give you a straight answer on what your feet need. Clinics across South East Queensland at Caboolture, Beenleigh, Browns Plains and Victoria Point.

Book an appointment

Where orthotics fit in a plan

Whatever device you end up with, it should sit inside a wider plan. With the right footwear, some strengthening and sensible load management, an orthotic has a fair chance of doing its job. On their own, the results in trials are often modest, which matches what I see when someone has been wearing the same pair for five years and nothing else has changed. So we start with an assessment. We work out what's driving your pain, decide whether an orthotic is the right tool at all, and if it is, find the simplest one that does the job.

Questions I get about orthotics

Custom or off-the-shelf?

For many everyday problems an off-the-shelf orthotic is fine, and for heel pain the trials show little difference between the two. Custom is worth considering for more complex feet: a deformity, big left-right differences, diabetes, or an area that needs precise offloading.

Do orthotics actually work?

For the right problem they can help, especially alongside footwear changes and strengthening. On their own, the results in trials are often modest.

Will I need them forever?

Not always. For some people they're long-term support for the way the foot is built. For others they're a tool to settle a problem while you build strength, and then you wean off them.

What's pedorthics?

Pedorthics is the field of providing medical grade footwear and orthotic devices. That includes modifying ready-made shoes and making custom footwear for feet that are hard to fit, and it sits comfortably alongside podiatry.

Want to know if orthotics are right for you? We'll assess your feet and only recommend what we think will help. Clinics at Caboolture, Beenleigh, Browns Plains and Victoria Point.

Book an appointment

References & further reading

This is general information, not individual advice. Whether orthotics suit you depends on your feet, so see a podiatrist for an assessment.


← Back to blog